Introduction
The pervasive and ever-expanding influence of artificial intelligence (AI) is a significant factor in modern global dynamics. The swift integration of AI across diverse sectors underscores a critical connection between the control of AI and national power, sparking an international race for AI supremacy. This global competition is marked by national AI initiatives, substantial investments in AI talent pools, and strategic efforts in the field of AI governance.
This intense technology competition is fueled by the recognition that attaining AI supremacy could confer unparalleled benefits across various domains, including economic strength, military capability, and global influence. The stakes are extraordinarily high, with countries increasingly aware of AI’s transformative potential and its implications for great power rivalry in the 21st century.
Key Takeaways
- The development of AI is a global endeavor, with countries like the US, China, France, and the UAE competing for leadership.
- This competition is fueled by the transformative potential of AI across various sectors, including transportation, healthcare, and more.
- Semiconductors, particularly AI accelerators, are essential for AI infrastructure, leading to strategic importance and geopolitical tensions, especially between the US and China.
- The US has implemented export controls on advanced AI chips to restrict China’s access to this technology.
- Despite these restrictions, Chinese AI firms remain resilient and are increasingly focused on self-reliance and developing their own large language models (LLMs).
- The demand for AI talent is high globally, leading to competitive compensation packages and a focus on attracting and retaining skilled individuals.
- France is emerging as a prominent AI hub in Europe, attracting investment from US tech giants like Microsoft, but its tax policies and energy costs pose potential challenges.
- The UAE is also heavily investing in AI, aiming to become a major player in the field with initiatives like the Falcon 2 LLM.
- Ethical considerations and regulations are crucial aspects of AI development, with ongoing debates about balancing innovation and responsible AI governance.
- Global cooperation and dialogue are essential to navigate the geopolitical and security implications of the AI race.
Jump to Sections
II. The Global Battle for AI Control: Shaping Tomorrow’s World
The expanding influence of AI is undeniably reshaping global power dynamics. Control over this transformative technology is increasingly viewed as a critical determinant of national power and competitiveness on the world stage. This has sparked a global battle for AI supremacy, with nations engaged in a strategic race to secure their place at the forefront of AI development and deployment.
Strategic Importance of AI
The race for AI supremacy is not merely a technological pursuit; it represents a struggle for economic dominance, military superiority, and geopolitical influence. AI is intertwined with critical aspects of national power:
- Economic Competitiveness: Mastery of AI promises to unlock significant economic advantages, driving innovation, boosting productivity, and creating new industries. The global competition for AI talent pools, as seen in the aggressive recruitment tactics of tech giants and the strategic investments by nations like France, underscores the recognition of AI’s potential to reshape the global economic landscape.
- Military Superiority: The potential applications of AI in warfare, including the development of autonomous weapons systems and advancements in algorithmic warfare, have added a critical security dimension to the quest for AI supremacy. Nations are acutely aware that dominance in AI could translate into a decisive military edge in future conflicts.
- Geopolitical Influence: As AI becomes increasingly central to various sectors, the ability to set global standards, shape AI governance frameworks, and influence the ethical development of AI will grant nations significant geopolitical leverage. US and China, in particular, are vying for influence in shaping the future of AI, evident in their diplomatic efforts and contrasting approaches to AI risk management.
Technological Decoupling and AI Sovereignty
Concerns over the potential misuse of AI and the pursuit of AI supremacy have also fueled a trend of technological decoupling, particularly between the US and China. This decoupling is evident in the US’s efforts to restrict China’s access to advanced AI chips and limit investments in China’s AI sector, reflecting a broader strategy to maintain its technological edge. China, in response, has emphasized the importance of “controllable” AI technology and is actively seeking to reduce its reliance on foreign technology, highlighting a growing emphasis on AI sovereignty.
The Stakes of Inaction
While the race for AI supremacy presents challenges and risks, failing to engage actively could leave nations at a significant disadvantage in the evolving global order. The development of national AI initiatives and strategic investments in research and infrastructure, as seen in France and the UAE, underscore the understanding that inaction is not a viable option in the age of AI.
The global battle for AI supremacy is not a distant prospect; it is a defining feature of the current geopolitical landscape. The decisions made today regarding the development, governance, and deployment of AI will have far-reaching consequences, shaping the balance of power for decades to come.
III. Key Players and Their Strategies
United States
The United States stands as a dominant force in the pursuit of AI supremacy, attracting a significant portion of global AI talent and hosting a majority of the world’s leading AI institutions. The U.S. is home to 60% of these top institutions, solidifying its position in AI research and development. To maintain its lead, the U.S. government has undertaken various efforts, including the National Artificial Intelligence Initiative (NAII), aimed at fostering continued leadership in AI research and development. However, the U.S. has expressed growing concerns over the potential misuse of AI, particularly by China. These concerns stem from the potential for AI to be used in activities such as election interference, bioweapon creation, and cyberattacks.
In response to these concerns, the U.S. has implemented a multi-pronged strategy to curb China’s access to sensitive technologies:
- Export Controls: The U.S. has imposed export controls on advanced computer chips, which are crucial for AI development, to limit China’s access to these technologies. This restriction extends to other sensitive technologies, with the U.S. revoking certain export licenses to companies like Huawei.
- Investment Restrictions: The U.S. government has taken steps to restrict investments in China’s AI and tech sectors. This includes President Biden’s executive order to limit U.S. investments in these areas, reflecting a broader strategy to maintain a technological edge over China. Additionally, the U.S. has issued draft rules to prohibit or require notification for certain investments in China’s AI and tech industries that could pose a threat to national security.
These actions highlight the U.S.’s assertive approach to safeguarding its AI supremacy, aiming to hinder China’s progress while simultaneously bolstering its domestic capabilities.
China
China is rapidly emerging as a prominent contender in the race for AI supremacy. The nation boasts a burgeoning domestic AI talent pool, now representing nearly half of the world’s top AI researchers. This growth aligns with the country’s strategic objective of establishing itself as a global AI hub. Although the U.S. currently hosts a greater number of top-tier AI institutions, China is actively fostering its domestic AI industry, as evidenced by the proliferation of large language models (LLMs) developed by Chinese organizations.
China’s strategy for achieving AI supremacy involves a multi-faceted approach:
- Welcoming U.S. AI Firms: In a notable shift towards international collaboration, China has expressed openness to U.S. AI firms operating within its borders. This strategy, endorsed by President Xi Jinping, aims to stimulate innovation, promote knowledge exchange, and expand market opportunities for both Chinese and U.S. companies.
- Promoting Innovation and Collaboration: By encouraging the presence of U.S. AI firms, China seeks to foster a vibrant ecosystem of innovation and knowledge sharing. This collaboration, involving the exchange of expertise, ideas, and technology, is expected to accelerate AI development on a global scale.
- Challenges Due to U.S. Restrictions: Despite China’s efforts to promote collaboration, it faces significant challenges due to U.S. export controls and investment restrictions. The U.S. government’s measures, driven by concerns over China’s potential misuse of AI, have particularly impacted China’s access to advanced AI chips. These restrictions have compelled Chinese companies to explore alternative pathways to acquire the necessary technology for AI development.
- Resilience and Innovation in the Face of Challenges: In response to these restrictions, Chinese AI firms like SenseTime and Baidu have demonstrated remarkable resilience and innovation. SenseTime, initially focused on facial recognition, has pivoted towards generative AI, developing its own LLM, SenseNova, positioned as a competitor to OpenAI’s GPT-4. Similarly, Baidu, a leading search engine giant in China, has called for the AI industry to prioritize the wider adoption of AI over solely focusing on LLM development, recognizing the challenges posed by chip limitations.
- Striving for Self-Reliance in AI Technology: China is actively encouraging domestic companies to achieve self-reliance in AI technology, aiming to reduce reliance on U.S. technologies. The government’s emphasis on developing “controllable” AI technology aligns with President Xi Jinping’s vision of technological self-sufficiency. This push for independence is evident in the significant investments made by China, such as the establishment of a multi-billion dollar state-backed chip fund to support the domestic semiconductor industry. Chinese companies are increasingly focused on developing their own proprietary AI models, with some claiming to rival OpenAI’s GPT-4 capabilities. The sources highlight a growing sentiment within China that OpenAI’s withdrawal from the Chinese market, while initially disruptive, presents a significant opportunity for domestic AI companies to strengthen their foothold and accelerate innovation.
Through these strategic initiatives, China is solidifying its position in the global AI arms race, demonstrating resilience and adaptability in its quest for AI supremacy amidst the complex landscape of technology competition and great power rivalry.
European Union: Navigating the Path to AI Supremacy
The European Union, despite possessing a strong foundation in AI research, faces significant challenges in keeping pace with the United States and China in the global race for AI supremacy. While the EU boasts a vibrant AI startup scene and renowned research institutions, factors such as a shortage of top-tier talent, fragmented national initiatives, and concerns about regulatory overreach threaten to hinder its progress.
The Struggle to Compete in the AI Talent Pool
Although France has emerged as a prominent hub for AI development within Europe, attracting substantial investment and fostering a growing ecosystem of AI startups, it still lags behind the US and China in terms of attracting and retaining top-tier AI talent. This talent crunch is partly attributed to the allure of higher salaries and more dynamic work environments offered by US tech giants. Despite France securing a significant portion of European AI startup funding, it faces stiff competition from the UK, which attracts more than double the investment in both AI and Generative AI.
This talent drain extends beyond France, impacting the entire EU. While Europe boasts numerous world-class researchers, many are drawn to the US and China, where they find greater opportunities and more generous funding. This brain drain threatens to leave Europe lagging in the race for AI breakthroughs.
Balancing Innovation and Regulation: The EU’s Approach
Recognizing the transformative potential of AI, the EU has taken a proactive stance in regulating the technology, aiming to establish ethical guidelines and mitigate potential risks. The recently approved AI Act, a landmark piece of legislation, reflects this commitment to responsible AI development. However, this emphasis on regulation has sparked debate, with some experts warning that overly restrictive measures could stifle innovation and hinder the EU’s competitiveness in the global AI landscape.
There are contrasting views on the EU’s approach to AI regulation. While some experts believe it’s necessary to ensure AI doesn’t become too powerful and to prevent potential misuse, others argue that regulations like the AI Act could inadvertently stifle innovation by imposing excessive restrictions on AI development. This debate highlights the delicate balancing act the EU faces between fostering innovation and safeguarding against potential risks. Striking the right balance between fostering innovation and ensuring responsible AI development will be crucial for the EU to secure a prominent position in the evolving landscape of AI supremacy.
Other Emerging Players: A Multipolar Landscape in the Quest for AI Supremacy
Beyond the established dominance of the US and China, a constellation of emerging players is actively vying for influence and recognition in the global pursuit of AI supremacy. These nations are adopting diverse strategies, leveraging their unique strengths, and grappling with distinct challenges in their respective journeys towards AI leadership.
France: A Blossoming AI Hub Navigating Challenges
As we already said, France has emerged as a significant AI hub in Europe, attracting considerable investments from US tech titans like Microsoft and Amazon. The nation’s appeal stems from its robust foundation in AI research, a burgeoning startup scene, and government support for national AI initiatives. Notably, Microsoft’s commitment of €4 billion signifies its largest investment in France to date, primarily directed towards bolstering cloud and AI infrastructure.
However, France faces obstacles in its pursuit of AI supremacy. High electricity costs pose a challenge, potentially dampening the growth of AI startups reliant on energy-intensive computing power. Furthermore, the potential limitations of tax incentives, particularly concerning the research tax credit (CIR), could hinder the financial viability of AI startups, impacting their ability to attract top talent and compete globally.
India: Harnessing AI for Local Solutions and Global Impact
Driven by a burgeoning ecosystem of AI startups and proactive government initiatives, India is making considerable progress in the global AI race. Startups like Observe AI, Pixis, Ola Krutrim, and SarvamAI exemplify India’s growing influence in AI innovation, attracting substantial funding and developing solutions across various sectors. Recognizing the potential of AI, the Indian government is actively supporting AI development through targeted national AI initiatives, fostering a conducive environment for innovation and growth.
India’s linguistic diversity, while presenting challenges for natural language processing (NLP) and automatic speech recognition (ASR), also offers unique opportunities. Developing AI solutions tailored to local needs and languages positions India to cater to a vast and diverse market, potentially establishing it as a leader in multilingual AI applications.
United Arab Emirates: Ambitious Strides and Strategic Partnerships in AI
The UAE is demonstrating a clear ambition to become a major AI player, strategically investing in AI infrastructure, talent acquisition, and research initiatives. A testament to its commitment is the release of Falcon 2, its own large language model designed to compete with those developed by established tech giants. This move highlights the UAE’s ambition to not just adopt but lead in AI innovation.
The UAE is actively fostering international collaborations to strengthen its AI capabilities. The recent $1.5 billion investment secured from Microsoft, coordinated with the US government, exemplifies this strategic approach. By partnering with global tech leaders, the UAE aims to accelerate its AI development and establish itself as a regional hub for AI innovation.
Saudi Arabia: Investing in AI Ecosystems Beyond US Dominance
Saudi Arabia is exhibiting a growing interest in AI, strategically investing in AI companies outside the US to diversify its technological portfolio and reduce reliance on any single power. The recent investment in Zhipu AI, a leading Chinese generative AI startup, exemplifies this strategy. By supporting promising AI companies in China, Saudi Arabia aims to foster a multipolar AI landscape, fostering competition and potentially influencing the direction of AI development beyond US dominance.
Russia: Navigating Geopolitical Tensions in Pursuit of AI Independence
Despite facing geopolitical challenges and sanctions, Russia, under the leadership of President Vladimir Putin, is determined to advance its AI capabilities and reduce dependence on Western AI technologies. Putin’s vision for AI extends beyond economic competitiveness, emphasizing its role in national security and global influence, including its applications in algorithmic warfare and autonomous weapons systems.
Russia faces obstacles in its quest for AI supremacy, particularly concerning access to advanced computing power and training data necessary for developing cutting-edge AI models. Sanctions imposed by the US and its allies have restricted Russia’s access to high-end AI chips, hindering its ability to keep pace with the rapid advancements in the field.
South Korea: Cultivating a Growing AI Talent Pool
South Korea is steadily emerging as a contender in the global AI supremacy race, recognized for its growing pool of talented AI researchers and engineers. The nation’s strength in electronics and technology provides a solid foundation for AI development, with companies like Samsung actively investing in AI research and applications.
While specific strategies employed by South Korea aren’t publicly available, its emergence as a prominent player in the AI talent pool landscape suggests a focus on education, research, and development initiatives to foster a thriving AI ecosystem.
IV. Challenges and Opportunities
Technological Challenges
- AI Chip Shortage: The global race for AI supremacy has precipitated a significant shortage of high-end AI chips essential for training advanced models. This scarcity critically hampers AI development, as the availability of these chips is pivotal for refining AI systems.
- Dependence on Taiwan’s TSMC: The global reliance on Taiwan’s TSMC, which manufactures 90% of the chips used for AI training, poses considerable risks. This dependency on a single company in a geopolitically sensitive region exposes the AI industry to vulnerabilities from geopolitical tensions or natural disasters, potentially disrupting AI progress worldwide.
Geopolitical Challenges
- US-China Tensions: The escalating rivalry between the U.S. and China over AI supremacy has heightened concerns about a potential technological Cold War. Both nations are heavily investing in AI research and development, striving to dominate this transformative technology. This competition extends to securing essential resources like AI chips and talent, intensifying geopolitical tensions.
- Exacerbating Existing Tensions: AI’s strategic importance could exacerbate existing geopolitical conflicts, particularly regarding Taiwan’s crucial role in chip manufacturing and disputes in the South China Sea. Disruptions in Taiwan’s chip supply could have extensive ramifications, potentially drawing other countries into the conflict and adding a technological dimension to the geopolitical landscape.
Ethical and Social Challenges
- Ethical Implications of AI: The rapid advancement of AI technology brings significant ethical challenges that require careful consideration.
- Job Displacement: As AI systems evolve, there are increasing concerns about job displacement across various sectors.
- Algorithmic Bias: AI algorithms can perpetuate and amplify societal biases, resulting in unfair or discriminatory outcomes. Addressing algorithmic bias is essential to ensure the ethical and responsible use of AI.
- Misuse for Malicious Purposes: AI’s potential for misuse, including disinformation, surveillance, and the development of autonomous weapons systems, raises substantial ethical concerns. International cooperation and the establishment of robust AI ethics frameworks are vital to mitigate these risks.
- Need for International Cooperation: Robust international cooperation and the development of comprehensive AI ethics frameworks are crucial for guiding the responsible evolution and utilization of AI. Collaborative efforts can help establish guidelines for AI governance, addressing ethical concerns and minimizing potential harms. Setting global standards and norms can prevent AI misuse and ensure its benefits are distributed widely while mitigating risks.
Opportunities
- Driving Innovation and Economic Growth: AI holds the potential to drive significant innovation and economic growth. By automating tasks, enhancing efficiency, and enabling new products and services, AI can revolutionize industries and create new economic opportunities, fostering job creation and economic development.
- Addressing Global Challenges: When developed and deployed responsibly, AI can play a crucial role in addressing global challenges.
- Climate Change: AI can analyze extensive datasets and model complex systems, aiding in developing strategies to mitigate and adapt to climate change.
- Disease Prevention and Treatment: AI can accelerate drug discovery, personalize healthcare, and improve disease diagnosis and treatment, leading to better health outcomes.
- Poverty Reduction: AI can develop targeted interventions, enhance resource allocation, and create opportunities for economic empowerment, contributing to poverty reduction efforts.
- International Cooperation for Maximizing Benefits: International cooperation is essential to maximize AI’s benefits and mitigate its risks. Sharing knowledge, resources, and best practices can accelerate AI development and ensure its advantages are accessible to all. Collaborative efforts can also address ethical concerns, promote responsible AI development, and prevent the technology’s malicious use. By working together, nations can harness AI’s transformative potential for the collective good while mitigating its risks.
- Â
V. Conclusion
The quest for AI supremacy has become a defining aspect of the 21st century, carrying profound implications for the future. This global race for AI dominance is multifaceted, involving not only technological innovation but also intense competition for talent, resources, and geopolitical influence.
This competition extends beyond the commonly cited US-China rivalry. Countries such as France, the UAE, and Saudi Arabia are making significant investments and advancements in AI, aiming to position themselves as pivotal players in this transformative technology. This widespread pursuit of AI leadership underscores the technology’s potential to reshape the geopolitical landscape.
International collaboration is crucial in addressing the challenges and opportunities presented by AI. While individual nations strive for AI supremacy, there is an emphasized need for cooperation in establishing robust AI ethics frameworks, ensuring responsible AI development, and managing the risks associated with this powerful technology.
The future of AI holds immense potential to transform the world, offering solutions to global challenges while posing unprecedented risks. International collaboration, guided by ethical considerations and a shared vision for a beneficial AI-powered future, will be essential in determining whether this influential technology ultimately benefits or endangers humanity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is there such high demand for AI talent, and who are the key players?
The rapid rise of AI technologies like ChatGPT has created a massive demand for skilled professionals who can develop and implement these systems. This has led to fierce competition between companies, often described as an “AI talent war.”
Key players in this war include established tech giants like Google (DeepMind), Microsoft, Amazon, and Nvidia, as well as ambitious startups like OpenAI, Mistral AI, and Inflection AI. These companies are offering lucrative salaries, stock options, and other benefits to attract and retain top talent.
How is the AI chip race reshaping global politics and security?
AI development relies heavily on powerful computer chips, particularly AI accelerators like those produced by Nvidia. However, the manufacturing of these chips is concentrated in a few key locations, notably Taiwan, raising geopolitical concerns.
China’s ambition to become an AI superpower is hindered by US export controls on advanced chips, leading to a race for technological self-sufficiency. This situation has placed Taiwan’s semiconductor industry, particularly TSMC, in a geopolitically sensitive position, with potential disruptions to chip supply chains posing a global risk.
What strategies are countries employing to gain an edge in the AI race?
Countries are employing a multi-pronged approach to secure their position in the AI race:
- Investment in Research and Development: Nations are increasing funding for AI research and development, including establishing dedicated funds and supporting university programs.
- Attracting and Retaining Talent: Governments are implementing policies to attract and retain AI talent, including offering visa incentives and fostering collaborative research environments.
- Developing Domestic Chip Manufacturing: To reduce reliance on foreign chipmakers, countries are investing heavily in building domestic semiconductor manufacturing capabilities.
- Fostering AI Startups: Incubator programs, tax incentives, and other initiatives are being used to support the growth of domestic AI startups.
Is China falling behind in the AI race despite its ambitions?
While China harbors ambitions to become a leading AI power, it faces challenges due to limited access to advanced AI chips and software. US export controls have restricted the flow of high-end Nvidia chips to China, impacting the development of advanced AI models.
However, Chinese companies are investing heavily in domestic chip manufacturing and developing their own AI models, like Baidu’s Ernie, showcasing resilience and innovation in the face of sanctions.
How are smaller countries positioning themselves in the global AI landscape?
Smaller countries are leveraging their unique strengths to carve out a niche in the global AI landscape.
- The UAE is investing heavily in AI infrastructure and talent, attracting major tech companies and aiming to become a global AI hub.
- France boasts a thriving AI startup scene, fueled by government incentives and support from US tech giants. However, the country faces challenges related to high electricity costs, impacting the cost of training AI models.
These countries demonstrate that strategic investments and a supportive ecosystem can enable even smaller nations to become significant players in the AI arena.
What is the future outlook for the global AI race?
The global AI race is expected to intensify in the coming years, with increasing investment, competition, and technological advancements. The development of more powerful AI models, the expansion of AI applications across various sectors, and the emergence of new players will shape the future of this rapidly evolving landscape.
International collaboration and responsible AI development practices will be crucial to harnessing the full potential of AI while mitigating its risks.
Glossary of Key Terms
- AI (Artificial Intelligence): The ability of a computer or machine to mimic human intelligence processes, such as learning, reasoning, and problem-solving.
- AI Chip: A specialized electronic circuit designed to accelerate artificial intelligence workloads, such as machine learning and deep learning.
- Generative AI: A type of AI that creates new content, like text, images, audio, and video, based on the data it has been trained on.
- Large Language Model (LLM): An AI model trained on a massive dataset of text and code, capable of generating human-quality text, translating languages, and writing different kinds of creative content.
- Semiconductor: A material that has electrical conductivity between that of a conductor and an insulator, essential for making integrated circuits used in computers and other electronic devices.
- GPU (Graphics Processing Unit): A specialized electronic circuit designed to rapidly manipulate and alter memory to accelerate the creation of images in a frame buffer intended for output to a display device.
- Venture Capital: A form of private equity financing provided by investors to startup companies and small businesses they believe have long-term growth potential.
- Unicorn Startup: A privately held startup company valued at over US$1 billion.
- Open Source: Software with source code that anyone can inspect, modify, and enhance.
- Digital Sovereignty: The ability of a nation-state to have control over its own digital destiny, including data, infrastructure, and technology.
Sources
- US raises concerns to Chinese officials about AI misuse | Reuters, 2024-05-15
- China Asking Its Tech Giants to Ditch Nvidia Chips and Buy Local | Business Insider, 2024-05
- Microsoft announces the largest investment to date in France to accelerate the adoption of AI, skilling and innovation | News Centre, 2024-05-13
- China is falling behind in race to become AI superpower | Semafor, 2024-05-08
- US delays AI chip exports to Middle East by Nvidia, AMD over concern that China can access the tech via data centres | South China Morning Post, 2024
- China will focus on AI in its new chip fund amid U.S. export curbs: professor | CNBC, 2024-05-29
- Saudi fund invests in China effort to create rival to OpenAI | Financial Times, 2024
- Malaysia targets over $100 bln in semiconductor industry investment | Reuters, 2024-05-28
- UAE releases new AI model to compete with big tech | Reuters, 2024-05-13
- In first AI dialogue, US cites ‘misuse’ of AI by China, Beijing protests Washington’s restrictions | AP News, 2024
- Japan’s Push for Open-Access Research | Perplexity.ai, 2024
- France is an AI hub, but a wrinkle in tax policy is holding it back | Semafor, 2024-05-29
- AI Talent Wars Have Big Tech CEOs Recruiting and Paying Huge Packages | Business Insider, 2024-04
- What Happens if Russia Catches Up in the AI Race? | AI Business, 2024
- US delays AI chip exports to Middle East by Nvidia, AMD over concern that China can access the tech via data centres | South China Morning Post, 2024
- Microsoft partners with Tencent to dominate China’s tech market | Rest of World, 2024
- China Welcomes U.S. AI Technology – A Leap Towards Global Cooperation | The AI Track, 2024
- China Asking Its Tech Giants to Ditch Nvidia Chips and Buy Local | Business Insider, 2024-05
- Dubai becomes the world metropolis for artificial intelligence | Yahoo Finance, 2024
- Chinese AI firms showcase resilience, innovations at AI event despite US sanctions | Reuters, 2024-07-05
